CASE STUDY · SEO AUDIT

Why a Spanish Contractor Lost Nearly 80% of Its Google Traffic, and Why the Redesign Was Not to Blame

The owner was sure his site restructuring caused the drop. Sixteen months of Search Console data showed it started long before.

Case study cover: the restructuring did not cause the drop, two Google core updates did
ClientMicrocement and flooring contractor
MarketSpain, Spanish-language site
ServiceTraffic drop audit and action plan
Delivered3 days ahead of schedule

The problem

Google clicks fell from about 25 a day in October 2025 to 5 to 8 a day in 2026, a drop of nearly 80% comparing October 2025 with October 2026. The main keyword, "microcement + city", fell from position 2.3 to 17.4.

In summer 2026 the owner had restructured the site with new pages, merged pages and redirects. He believed this work had caused the fall. Before changing anything else, he needed to know what happened, whether the redirects were broken, and what to fix first.

Bar chart of average Google clicks per day falling from 22.2 to 10.2 after the December 2025 core update and to 6.9 after the March 2026 core update, with the later restructuring shown as no further fall
Average Google clicks per day, 28 days before and after each core update. Source: Search Console.

What I checked

I matched every drop in the data to a date and a cause, then confirmed each finding on the live site.

What I found

The restructuring was not the cause. Clicks fell in two steps, both starting on the first days of Google's December 2025 and March 2026 core updates. By May 2026 traffic was already at today's level, three months before the restructuring began.

-54%clicks after the December 2025 core update
53 pagesnear-duplicate company and location pages
~1,000thin tag pages open to Google
10 of 10redirects tested and working
FindingEvidence
Timing of the dropBoth falls began on core update start dates, months before the restructuring
Overlapping pages115 posts updated before the December drop; 53 near-duplicate location and company pages
Main keywordHomepage fell from about position 3 to 23; the map listing still ranked near the top but showed less often
Trust signalsFour different claims about years of experience, stock-style images, no reviews on the site
IndexingIndexed pages fell from 802 to 503 as Google dropped weaker pages
Business ProfileWrong primary category and an http:// website link
Tracking and speedQuote requests not tracked as conversions; all tracked mobile pages rated Poor for speed
Ruled out: the restructuring, manual penalty, security issues, HTTPS problems, broken redirects and spam backlinks, which appeared after both drops.

The most useful finding was the simplest: Google still showed the site for its commercial searches, just lower. That is a ranking loss, not a visibility loss, and it is the most recoverable kind.

Audit findings, each labelled Confirmed, Likely or Ruled out

The recovery plan

The plan was written so the owner could carry it out himself. Every step names the exact menu, field and button in WordPress, Search Console, GA4 or the Business Profile.

Phase 1

Fix what is broken

Redirect chains, old sitemap entries, quote tracking, Business Profile category, one consistent experience claim

Phase 2

Consolidate

Retitle the main flooring page, merge competing pages one group at a time, 4 weeks apart

Phase 3

Clean up thin pages

Reduce near-duplicate location pages and stop tag pages from being indexed

In parallel

Speed and trust

Mobile loading speed, real project photos and reviews on the site

An Excel tracker with 12 sheets turned the plan into 20 prioritised actions, each with a status column, plus the redirect tests, competing pages and keywords. The full report and tracker were delivered in English and Spanish.

What the client received: diagnostic report, 12-sheet Excel tracker, 20 prioritised actions, delivered 3 days early

Client feedback

★★★★★

Rated 5 out of 5 on Fiverr.

Owner, microcement and flooring contractor, Spain

The owner now knows his restructuring was not the problem, and he is working through the plan himself. Recovery after a core update usually shows at the next update once fixes are in place, typically within 3 to 6 months.

Planning to undo changes because your traffic dropped? Find the real cause first. I'll check your data and give you a clear, step-by-step plan.

Get In Touch

Related Reading

Awatif Mazhar
Written by Awatif Mazhar, an SEO Content Lead with a background in dentistry and a certification in digital marketing. She builds content strategies and architectures for healthcare, e-commerce, and service businesses, and has scaled organic content reaching over 1M impressions. More on this topic →